Human traffickers could be put to death under new bill

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

SALT LAKE CITY -- Criminals convicted of human trafficking could soon be eligible for the death penalty.

On Tuesday a bill was passed by a House committee that would give prosecutors the right to seek the death penalty in any human trafficking case in which a victim dies.

"That could be you're the one that coerced him or kidnapped him into the trafficking, maybe you are the coyote that is driving a truck load of people and maybe they fell in the truck and died in the back of the truck," said Rep. Paul Ray, R-Clearfield, who proposed House Bill 136. "I think justice is deserved and I think we need to deliver justice for these victims."

Those in the community against the bill say the death penalty is not the answer.

"The death penalty is not going to solve the problem, I think we need to look at real solutions to the problem and not just simply trying to expand the use of the death penalty," said Jean Hill of the Catholic Diocese.

According to the Utah Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, prosecuting a capitol murder case from trial to execution costs about $1.6 million.

"It doesn't make sense that we are not giving those resources to the individuals that are truly affected," said Virginia Ward, of Journey of Hope.

Ray said not one dollar of state money would be spent as a result of this bill. It's up to each individual county prosecutor to decide if they have the justification and resources to pursue the death penalty.

"It's not always about sending messages and trying to prevent, it’s about punishing somebody that has committed the worst of crimes," said Tom Ross, who represents the Utah Chiefs of Police Association.

When it comes to criminals being sentenced to the death penalty in Utah, it's very rare regardless of the crime. Only one person has been sentenced to death in the last 15 years and only seven since 1976.

This bill now moves onto the full house.


  • tkwaltz

    The people who deal in human lives buying and selling humans using them as slave labor and worse. They dont care about a death penalty, it will not detract them from what they do, they have no soul no conscious This is the dumbest law ever it is grandstanding telling people look what we did knowing full well at the inception of the law it will not deter anyone. politics
    as usual..

  • Karl Hegbloom (@KarlHegbloom)

    Title 18 USC s241 & s242 already authorize the death penalty for crimes against rights. If a new law is passed they get an ex post facto defense for past crimes for which properly there is no statute of limitations. The right violated is the right to personal autonomy, bodily integrity, and to live, all fundamental basic rights inherent in malum in se crimes by definition. I’m pretty sure that these laws are not restricted to application only when a government actor commits the crime. When the federal code was renumbered, internal links between the civil rights laws did not get updated. A finding of liability or rights infringement or violation under Title 42 USC s1985 or s1983 implies a Title 18 USC s241 or s242 crime, and Title 18 USC s14141 means that the offender is expected to be prosecuted.

  • Vavlvavlvlv

    An illegal alien could fall out of a truck carrying them to Utah and the truck driver would get the death penalty according to this bill if the courts thought the alien was ‘coerced’ to come to America. Very general. Involuntary manslaughter charges might make sense, but this bill is nonsensical.

Comments are closed.