Confederate flag comes down at South Carolina Capitol after half century

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

The Confederate battle flag flies on the grounds of the South Carolina State House in Columbia on July 5, 2015.

For 54 years the Confederate battle flag fluttered in the breeze on South Carolina’s Capitol grounds — proudly, defiantly. Through passionate pleadings and stormy condemnations to lower it, to hide it from plain sight.

On Friday morning, it came down.

It was lowered for the last time, furled and sent to the South Carolina Confederate Relic Room & Military Museum, where it will be housed.

The political winds changed quickly for the flag after a racist massacre at the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston in June.

The steadfast support for the flag as an affirmation of Southern heritage waned against the overwhelming awareness of the battle flag’s deeply painful meaning: a banner of racial subjugation for many.

It was time to go.

The ceremony was brief. There were no remarks. But that didn’t mean it wasn’t full of emotion, including loud cheers and even chants of “U.S.A.” and “Nah, nah, nah, hey, hey goodbye.”

Like the flag’s presence itself, the cheering was loud.

From its origin in the battlefields of the Civil War to its place in a museum, here’s a time line of the rebel flag that flew over the South Carolina State House:

1861: Born of battle

The Confederate battle flag was designed to stick out, to be recognizably different. It was never the political flag of the Confederate states, although it was integrated into it over the course of the Civil War war into its canton — its upper left field.

The original Confederate flag looked much like the Union flag at the time. So much so, that soldiers on the battle field had a hard time telling the two — and their respective armies — apart, when gun smoke clouded the theater. Confederate Gen. Pierre G.T. Beauregard wanted something vividly dissimilar. Politician William Porcher Miles came up with the design we know today — the battle flag: a blue St. Andrew’s Cross with white stars on a red field.

1961: Resurrected over the Capitol dome

After the Civil War, the battle flag mostly faded from sight. But little less than a century later, after World War II, the civil rights movement began to simmer, and the flag slowly reappeared. South Carolina politician Strom Thurmond ran for president as the face of the newly founded racial segregationist party, the Dixiecrats. He was often greeted at rallies with Confederate battle flags.

By the 1960s the civil rights movement was bursting forth. In January 1961 John F. Kennedy was sworn in as President, promising equal rights to African-Americans, and desegregation progressed. Three months later, on April 11, 1961, South Carolina hoisted the battle flag over the Capitol dome in Columbia to honor the 100th anniversary of the beginning of the Civil War. And kept it there.

2000: Moved to a lower spot

Political uproar over the flag over the dome grew. And in 2000, civil rights activists succeeded in lobbying to have the large Confederate flag removed from that prominent position. As a compromise, the legislature passed the 2000 Heritage Act, which had the flag raised next to a soldiers’ monument and protect its position there. It required a two-thirds majority vote by the legislature to overturn it.

June 17, 2015: Stained by a massacre

On June 17, Dylann Roof sat down for Bible class in a historic African-American church in Charleston. For an hour, he listened to the lesson given by Rev. Clementa Pinckney, who was also a state senator. Then, he drew a semi-automatic pistol and told the class that he had come to kill black people. He shot dead nine, including Pinckney, and fled. Soon after his arrest, photos surfaced of Roof holding a pistol and the Confederate battle flag, which he revered as a symbol of white supremacy.

June 18, 2015: Marked for removal

The next day, Gov. Nikki Haley had the American and the South Carolina state flags flying over the Capitol dome lowered to half-staff. But the Confederate flag on the state Capitol grounds continued to fly, defiantly, at the top of its mast. Social media erupted with outrage.

A day later, Roof faced loved ones of his victims via video link. They showered him with forgiveness and grief and prayed for his soul. And public sympathies for their pain deepened. It triggered a chain reaction. Conservative politicians, who in the past defended the flag, called for its removal. And businesses such as Walmart and Amazon struck the flag from their stock.

June 27, 2015: Brought down by an activist

President Obama gave a rousing eulogy at Pinckney’s funeral that turned into an oratory calling for national unity on race. At the end he broke into a rendition of “Amazing Grace.” A bipartisan group of mourners flew in from Washington, giving the memorial the character of a state funeral.

The next day, on June 27, activist Bree Newsome shimmied up the flagpole and took it down but was arrested, and the flag was re-raised.

July 8, 2015: Voted out by numbers

The state Senate swiftly passed a bill to remove the flag permanently from its pole. But when it hit the House floor, roadblocks went up. A handful of Confederate flag supporters introduced 68 nit-picking amendments — effectively holding up a vote on the Senate bill. Republican Rep. Jenny Horne, could take it no longer. She took to the podium to address the chamber, looked over to her black legislative colleagues, then blew up in tears in a fiery speech.

“I cannot believe that we do not have the heart in this body,” she said, pausing to swallow her sobs, then raising her voice to shout, “to do something meaningful, such as take a symbol of hate off these grounds on Friday.” She thrust her finger at the floor with every word of her demand. After half a day of legislative battle, the House overwhelmingly passed the bill.

July 10, 2015: Sent to its resting place

On July 9, Haley signed the bill into law with nine pens, one for each of the victims killed at Emanuel AME Church. The pens were made gifts to their loved ones.

On July 10, around 10 a.m., two members of the South Carolina state highway patrol, took down the flag the Confederate flag and then handed it to Leroy Smith, director of South Carolina’s Department of Public Safety. Smith is African-American.

Now it takes on a new life — this time as a museum piece.

5 comments

  • J

    Wow, just wow. Really? It is considered offensive to pledge allegiance to the AMERICAN flag! Nobody even knows to stand with hand over heart when the AMERICAN flag is presented in a parade etc. People cheer on AMERICAN flag burners! And one small confederate flag, in one state, can be the cause for great battle, hate, anger, and pleas for change! It can even make “breaking news” status. It’s not that I don’t understand the feelings behind it all, but, keep things in perspective maybe.

  • bob

    It’s neither the Confederate Flag, nor the “Confederate Battle Flag.” It’s the Battle Flag of the Army of Northern Virginia, so it didn’t make a lot of sense in that context anyway. It was Robert E. Lee’s battle flat. Lee was anti-slavery, and was against secession. He was offered overall command of the Union Army by Lincoln, at the White House, the day before he resigned his commission to fight for Virginia. He decided he could not turn against his friends and neighbors.

    The Civil War was not fought over slavery. Only 4.6% of Southern Whites owned slaves, according to the 1860 census. A higher percentage of free blacks in the south were slave owners. A whopping 28% of the 10,000 free black residents of New Orleans, for example.

    Even fewer Confederate soldiers were slave owners.

    Slavery was legal under the laws of the United States until two years into the war, and even then the Emancipation Proclamation, noble as it was, was not supported by the Constitution. Slavery was also supported by multiple Supreme Court decisions, and whites in several NORTHERN states were required by law to return runaway slaves to their owners. It is absurd to suggest that the flag “represents slavery.” Only in the minds of the ignorant does it do so.

    • bob

      Lincoln, who had said many times that the war was not against slavery, intended the illegal Emancipation Proclamation to stir up a stagnant war effort by encouraging abolitionists in the North to sign up in greater numbers.

      It had the opposite effect. “Emancipation” ignited massive draft riots in the North, especially in New York City. People who were ambivalent about fighting for “the Union” were absolutely furious about fighting against “slavery”, as they now perceived it.

      This is what happens when people no longer study history. They only get the cartoon version, in the 5th grade, and that’s it.

Comments are closed.