New York woman arrested after pit bulls maul man; video shows bystanders may have saved his life

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Screen capture courtesy Kenny Williams on YouTube.

By Ray Sanchez and Lorenzo Ferrigno


NEW YORK (CNN) — A pair of pit bulls left Francesco Bove so badly mutilated that a priest read him his last rites outside a New York church.

“I think I’m going to die,” the bloodied 62-year-old artist told the priest, Bove’s son, Anthony, recalled Saturday. “But the priest made him promise that he will fight until the end.”

The gruesome attack Friday was captured on video from the window of a tenement in the Bronx. The pit bulls are seen clamping Bove’s arms with their jaws, shaking their heads violently, dragging him several feet toward to the curb. The video courtesy of Kenny Williams on YouTube is available below.

WARNING: The footage below contains raw/graphic footage of the animal attack, and viewer discretion is advised.

Good Samaritans try to stop the assault — swinging a chain at the animals, spraying them with a water. They attempt to encircle Bove but the canines swerved around to continue the attack. They probably helped save Bove’s life.

“I got to the hospital and he was in pieces,” Anthony Bove said of his father, describing gaping holes in the arms, a severed ear and another split in half, lacerations throughout the body.

The horror began when the dogs’ owner, Cynthia Oliver, 55, exchanged words with the victim, said NYPD spokeswoman, Det. Annette Markowski. Oliver was holding the pit bulls and dropped the leash, she said. The dogs attacked.

But Anthony Bove said his father told him there was no altercation. No words exchanged.

Francesco was walking to Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church when one of the dog pounced, followed by the other, according to the son.

“The dogs started biting,” Anthony Bove said. “He’s trying to push them away. They overpower him.”

Oliver was taken to a hospital for a psychological evaluation before she was arrested on eight counts of assault and two counts of reckless endangerment, Markowski said. It’s unclear whether she has an attorney.

In the video, another man steps in to help after Bove is knocked to the ground. The man uses his hands and legs to keep the dogs at bay but the animal find their way back to Bove.

The Good Samaritan is knocked down. Screams are heard. “Let him go!” someone yells.

At least eight people on the street try to help as the pit pulls drag Bove away from the small crowd.

A woman can be heard off camera. It seems she is frantically calling 911. “These two dogs are outside attacking this man!”

One man is seen firing a stream of water at the dogs with a hose. Bove lies in a pool of blood.

“Hurry up, these dogs are attacking a man!” the woman yells off camera. “He’s in the street bleeding!”

Police said the 62-year-old victim and the first man who jumped in to help — an unidentified 46-year-old male — were taken to St. Barnabas Hospital. The younger man, who suffered lacerations on his arms, was later released, according to Anthony Bove.

Francesco Bove, an artist and restoration expert from Brooklyn, is in stable condition after undergoing surgery, according to his son. His severed ear was reconstructed. He will have another operation on Monday.

“My father joked, ‘If those were two lions, I wouldn’t have made it,'” Anthony Bove said. “He’s a really tough guy.”

The elder Bove suffered nerve damage in his hands and hasn’t been able to move his fingers, according to the son.

“He’s an artist and does high-end renovation,” Anthony Bove said. “He’s very passionate about his art. If he couldn’t move his hands I don’t know how he wound take that psychologically.”

The pit bulls are now in custody of animal control authorities, Markowski said.

That worries the Boves, who own a pit bull named Gina as well as five cats.

“My father feels terrible that the dogs are probably going to be put to sleep,” Anthony Bove said.

“The pit bull is not an inherently evil dog. But … these pit bulls might have been trained as guard or attack dogs. He remembers the dogs licking his blood off the ground. They wanted to finish the job. That’s very disturbing to him.”

™ & © 2015 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.



    This story can’t possibly be true. Pit bulls just don’t have a history of attacking people. Right?
    And yes, pit bull lovers, it is the breed.

    • Ddd

      If she would have had Rottweilers or German shepherds or dobermans or most other bigger breeds I could name, the same thing would have happened, my point being, she is a bad person who made her dogs be bad also.. I mean she argued with an elderly person and seeked her dogs on him! I wonder what would have happened if she had a gun on her??

      • Ddd

        Right!? it’s such a dangerous breed, that’s why millions of them are used as service dogs for disabled people,, And rescue animals.

      • bob

        Order a Beagle to attack someone, and see what happens. Try TRAINING a Beagle to attack someone, in fact.

        My daughter just HAD to have a pit bull. It was a requirement, since she likes to listen to rap. The dog was her baby. Pampered, obedience trained, never abused. And he was a friendly, tail-wagging dog. Everything pit bull apologists claim the breed to be.

        Until he snapped.

  • Magen

    I like how that father is standing in the middle of the street with his small child while these dogs haven’t been contained yet. This is an unfortunate event, and another bad dog owner giving this breed of dogs a bad name.


      Put bulls have earned their reputation as vicious animals all on their own Magen. They don’t need any help from their owners.

  • mKm

    Who made the determination that they are “Pit Bulls”? Was it determined by genetic testing or is it dogs that look like “Pit Bull” like Apollo from Miami-Dade county?

  • Pedro

    How disturbing. I own a Pitt Bull and have not had any problems. Very loving dog. It has taken hours and hours of training and I am still very cautious with her. I put her away when people come over and always keep her leashed on walks. Pitt Bulls can be vicious and that is exactly what I count on when somebody decides to break into my home.

    • MIKE

      Pit bulls only have one (1) “T” Pedro. Your comment, if you are to be believed, suggests that you don’t even trust your dog,

      • Pedro

        Exactly. I am not an advocate claiming Pit bulls are gentle creatures who just need love. They were bread to attack. They were historically used to take down large animals to include bears. They would bite down on the animal’s face and not let go due to their extremely powerful locked jaw. I trust my dog completely with me and my family, but due to their protective instinct I have to use caution around everyone else. I do not think she would attack someone, but you can never guess with a 100% certainty what the animal may perceive as a threat, so I use caution. She is a family pet, but also a security measure. Just like you wouldn’t leave your home defense weapon laying around with guests and children present, you also need to take safety measures with pets bred to protect. It is about personal responsibility.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.