Brianne Altice sentenced for sex with students

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

FARMINGTON, Utah -- A former Davis High School teacher convicted of having sex with three students has been sentenced to serve up to 30 years in prison.

Brianne Altice, 35, tearfully apologized as she pleaded with the judge for mercy during a lengthy sentencing hearing on Thursday.

"I've learned lessons beyond what you can imagine," she said.

Altice asked the judge not to sentence her to prison, saying her children needed her and she wanted to turn her life around. She spoke about the media attention that has surrounded the case.

"A lot of judgments have been made by minds that don't know me, by mouths that have never asked me a question and ears that have never heard my side," she said. "One day you're loved, the next day you're a target."

But Altice said she would persevere, declaring: "Though I am flawed, I am better than this."

Altice pleaded guilty in April to three counts of forcible sex abuse, a second-degree felony. In exchange for the plea, Davis County prosecutors dismissed 11 other felony charges, including first-degree felony rape.

Altice was convicted of having sexual relationships with three teen boys, who were students at Davis High School in Kaysville. Her defense attorney, Ed Brass, argued she was not the boys' teacher when the sexual relationships took place. The judge, however, did rule that she was in a position of trust over them.

"She was relentlessly pursued for months by these young men," Brass told the judge on Thursday. "I'm not excusing what she did. She's plead guilty to some very serious crimes, there's no question about that."

While Davis County prosecutors acknowledged the teenage boys were flirtatious with Altice, they pointed out she was in a position to say no to any misconduct and she caused real harm to her victims.

"Society for some reason says, 'Well, they're boys, they're men. This would be any kid's fantasy,'" said Deputy Davis County Attorney Cristina Ortega. "It's not. This is real life."

The mother of one of the boys told the judge she believed Altice was grooming him.

"She chose to act inappropriately with my son. She can blame these boys for thinking she’s pretty, she can blame other people for not catching on sooner. She can even blame me for taking the steps to report her. But at the end of the day, she chose to make the decision," the woman (whom FOX 13 is not naming because her child is a victim of sex abuse) told the judge.

The woman spoke about the double standard between male teachers and female teachers. Second District Court Judge Thomas Kay said he was sentencing not based on gender, but conduct.

"The point is, you're the teacher. You're the adult," he told Altice.

Judge Kay sentenced Altice to serve 1-to-15 years in prison for each count of forcible sex abuse. He ordered two of those charges to be served consecutively, meaning she will serve up to 30 years. Altice was given credit for time behind bars and ordered to undergo sex offender treatment.

Handing down sentence, Judge Kay questioned if she was truly remorseful.

"I don't know if you are taking responsibility," he said. "I also wonder if you're in denial about what you've done?"

17 comments

  • Tace

    That is extreme, most people get off with less time. Especially women offenders. I bet it was because she wasn’t very remorseful.

  • Remove the judge

    This judge should be removed. 30 years is ridiculous. Truly violent repeat offenders get less than 30 years for their crimes.

    • ANOTHERBOB

      The judge applied the laws that applied to her crimes. Too bad she didn’t think of her children earlier.

    • Zethicz

      Nope, and this is fair so shut up and deal with it. Plus if a adult man did this to a teenage girl we all know what would of happened don’t we people? Also she just couldn’t go to a college campus and “go at it” with the guys their that were actually legal or at least use a site like “ashleymadison” to get her groove on. Glad to see this starting to be taken seriously rather than see those other female teachers get at least probation or a few months in jail.

  • 8ch

    Altice asked the judge not to sentence her to prison, saying her children needed her and she wanted to turn her life around————— Her children needed her on those days and nights she was spending time with teenage boys too.

  • Heather Chinn

    The schools need to have a statement written in the new hire packet saying you can’t have sexual relations with minors. Maybe she honestly didn’t know she was doing wrong. We only care when it’s happening to us, and all the sudden we’re landed in court. I think it could be possible she sue Davis High School, for not mentioning this in the new hire packet.

  • miles (dave)

    yesterday when they were talking about this case they mentioned that this judge did not determine the “real” sentence but a ball park one meaning she cant serve for more than 30yr. they said the parole board world determine her “real” sentence

  • lammas martti

    Totally absurd judgment! In Europe is said that the American are idiots, and I do not wonder why. Greetings from WEST-EUROPE !

  • Nicole

    I absolutely agree with her sentence and hope every moment of the 30 years is served. I am a mother and I have taught my son that you can trust and turn to your teacher, no parent wants to have to worry about the teacher doing something like this when you’ve placed your trust in that person to educate your child and not to bring harm to them.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.