Salt Lake making changes after parking meters found not in compliance with city codes

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

SALT LAKE CITY -- At the height of rush hour in downtown Salt Lake City, it can be hard to find parking, and for some, it's even harder to pay once you do.

“My cards are rejected a lot lately, and they just don’t work a lot of the time,” Ryan Fedor said, who works downtown.

In 2011-12, the city replaced its old parking meters with new kiosks, which allowed drivers to pay with coins, a credit card or even their phone.

Now many argue they’re not as user-friendly as they appear.

“They get too hot and they don’t work,” Peter Marshall said, owner of Utah Book and Magazine on Main St.

It’s those kinds of complaints from the public that Salt Lake City could be paying for in the future, according to attorney Bruce Baird.

“Big bureaucracies make mistakes,” Baird said. “This mistake is going to wind up costing the city millions and millions of dollars.”

Last month, Baird filed a lawsuit against the city, arguing their parking codes don’t apply to the new kiosks they put in a couple years ago.

Now, he’s adding plaintiffs in an amended complaint and seeking to have it certified as a class action suit, in order to recoup fees for not only parking tickets, but all money paid.

“It could be $5-6 million a year because there’s no legal basis for the city to be collecting the base revenue from the meters either,” Baird said. “So, the amended complaint will seek to get the base revenue, as well.”

His argument is based on current city code, which only reflects the old parking meters that were on the streets before the kiosks.

In 2012, the city’s Community and Economic Development Office sent a notice to the council, recommending they update and amend their parking ordinances but for some reason, it wasn't done.

“We’re still investigating why that didn't occur, and so, I think what our objective is now is to move forward and get it taken care of,” Salt Lake City council chair Charlie Luke said.

Tuesday night the council voted to update the city’s parking codes during its formal meeting.

“We just want to take care of it as quickly as possible, which is why it’s on the agenda for tonight,” Luke said.

However, while that solves one problem, Baird said he believes it’s only the beginning of many more for the city and its parking.

“Obviously, the city is fixing the ordinance tonight, a day late and about $10 million short,” Baird said.


  • Barbara R.

    Okay and who gets the base revenue refund? I agree with most of what he says, but I don’t agree with going after base revenue. To me that seems kind of greedy. The law needs to be changed yes, but at the end of it all who really pays for the law suit? Yep the taxpayers.

  • John Rohrbaugh

    We went to eat at Cannella’s about 2 weeks ago and the machine near their place the Blue button didn’t work to add time. The one down from it kept rejecting my cards and I quit after the 4th try. I went into Cannella’s and told the rest of our party we were heading to Faustina’s instead since they have their own parking lot! I told the folks at Cannella’s I won’t pay $15 for the privilege of eating at their place because for sure Mayor Becker’s tickets will be promptly issued regardless of the machines working or not!

  • dave

    does anyone know where the money from parking goes? i dont know it feels like thats something you shouldn’t get charged for probably because i grew up never having to do it, but ive never payed to park anywhere. to me it feels like having to pay to use the bathroom. in salt lake ill usually drive around the block just so i dont have to pay, then ill walk. it works for me and i dont feel like im getting raped.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.