Oscar Pistorius neighbor ends her time on the stand with emotional testimony

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

South African Paralympic athlete Oscar Pistorius sits quietly on his own after arriving at the High Court in Pretoria, South Africa on Tuesday, 4 March 2014.

By Richard Allen Greene

PRETORIA, South Africa (CNN) — A defense attorney tried to poke holes in highly emotional testimony Tuesday of the first witness in the murder trial of Olympian double-amputee Oscar Pistorius.

Testimony continued with the questioning of Pistorius’ neighbor, Michelle Burger, who said in Monday’s first day of testimony that she was awakened by screams, followed by gunshots, when Pistorius shot and killed his girlfriend, model Reeva Steenkamp, on Valentine’s Day last year. On Tuesday, defense attorney Barry Roux attacked Burger’s credibility, accusing her of using her husband’s statement to craft her own.

Paragraph by paragraph, Roux pointed out similarities between their two statements. Burger repeatedly explained that the statements were similar because they both heard the same thing. “I’m as honest as I can be to the court,” she said.

Pistorius has admitted he killed Steenkamp but pleaded not guilty Monday, saying that he mistakenly believed he was shooting a burglar. He only realized after firing four shots that his girlfriend was not in bed but in the bathroom he was firing at, his defense team said on his behalf Monday.

Burger broke down in court when she described Steenkamp’s screams. Through her tears, she said, “It was awful to hear her screams.”

At one point, Pistorius clutched his head in his hands as an expert described how bullets struck Steenkamp’s head.

On Monday, Burger testified that, “Something terrible was happening at that house. She called the shouts and screams “petrifying.”

Finally, after brief questioning by prosecutor Gerrie Nel, Burger was excused.

The case has fascinated South Africa and much of the world, with its high-profile defendant, the double-amputee track star so talented that he competed not only in the Paralympics but against able-bodied runners in the Olympics two years ago.

Burger lives several hundred yards from where the killing took place.

During Nel’s questioning Monday, Burger told the court that she heard a woman’s screams and a man yelling for help.

“Just after 3, I woke up from a woman’s terrible screams,” she said. “Then I also heard a man screaming for help. Three times he yelled for help.”

She assumed a nearby home was being invaded by criminals.

She later told her husband that she feared the woman had witnessed her husband being shot “because after he screamed, we didn’t hear him.”

Roux spent hours hammering Burger with questions in Monday’s cross-examination, asking repeatedly if there could have been shots before she woke up, if she was sure about the sequence of events and about her knowledge of guns.

He asked if the “bang” sounds she heard might not have been gunshots, but rather a cricket bat bashing at a bathroom door.

She answered that she had clearly heard gunshots, testily answering Roux’s questions about how much time had elapsed between them, saying she “didn’t sit there with a stopwatch and take down the timing of each shot.”

Moments of low comedy

Despite the deadly serious subject of the trial, there were lighter moments, such as when Roux said that when Pistorius is anxious, “it sounds like a woman screaming.”

“I’m 100% certain I heard two different people that evening,” Burger insisted.

There was repeated confusion, irritation and befuddlement over the language Burger testified in. She spoke Afrikaans, her native language, and had an interpreter translate her words into English.

But she regularly corrected her interpreter’s English and had a brief discussion in English with the judge about whether she should testify in that language.

She and the judge agreed she would continue to testify in Afrikaans, but she repeatedly lapsed back into English.

And when defense lawyer Roux quoted her police statement in Afrikaans, raising questions about whether she said she’d heard one scream or many, prosecutor Nel interrupted — in English — to object that Roux’s line of questioning implied something grammatically impossible in Afrikaans.

He also faces weapons charges

Pistorius pleaded not guilty Monday to all four charges against him, which include weapons charges as well as the accusation he murdered Steenkamp.

It’s expected to take at least three weeks for Judge Thokozile Matilda Masipa to hear the case and decide whether Pistorius mistook Steenkamp for a burglar or killed her in cold blood.

South Africa abolished jury trials in 1969.

Pistorius faces one charge of murder and a firearms charge associated with Steenkamp’s killing, as well as two gun indictments unrelated to Steenkamp.

In South Africa, premeditated murder carries a mandatory life sentence, with a minimum of 25 years. He also could get five years for each gun indictment and 15 years for the firearms charge.

If he isn’t convicted of premeditated murder, the sprinter could face a lesser charge of “culpable homicide,” a crime based on negligence, and could be looking at up to 15 years on that charge, experts say.

Parts of Pistorius’ trial are being televised live — a first in South Africa — after a judge’s decision last week allowing cameras in the courtroom. But witnesses have the option of not having their images televised. Burger took that option, and only her voice was broadcast.

June Steenkamp, Reeva Steenkamp’s mother, was in the courtroom for Monday’s testimony, marking the first time she had laid eyes on Pistorius in person. The two had never met before.

Steenkamp’s parents have avoided previous court appearances because they wanted privacy.

Pistorius’ brother and sister were also present for Monday’s proceedings.

Dream couple

Pistorius, now 27, and Steenkamp, 29 when she died, were a young, attractive, high-profile couple popular in South Africa’s social circles.

Pistorius, nicknamed the “Blade Runner” because of the special prostheses he uses while running, won six Paralympic gold medals and became the first double-amputee runner to compete in the Olympics, in London in 2012.

Cover girl Steenkamp, who was soon to star in a TV reality show, was on the cusp of becoming a celebrity in her own right.

Everything changed before dawn on Valentine’s Day 2013, as Steenkamp lay lifeless in a pool of blood on the floor of her boyfriend’s house in an upscale gated community in Pretoria.

Moments before, Pistorius says, he had pointed his 9 mm pistol toward an upstairs toilet room and fired four bullets through the locked door.

In court documents, Pistorius has said he heard a noise from the bathroom in the middle of the night and — feeling vulnerable without his prosthetic legs on — charged toward the bathroom on his stumps.

He has said he shot through the toilet door in order to protect himself and Steenkamp.

“I felt a sense of terror rushing over me,” he said in his court affidavit. “There are no burglar bars across the bathroom window, and I knew that contractors who worked at my house had left the ladders outside.”

“It filled me with horror and fear of an intruder or intruders being inside the toilet. I thought he or they must have entered through the unprotected window. As I did not have my prosthetic legs on and felt extremely vulnerable, I knew I had to protect Reeva and myself.”

Prosecutors are painting a different picture. They say the pair had an argument and that Steenkamp locked herself in the toilet.

At last year’s bail hearing, the state said Pistorius put on his prosthetic legs, collected his gun from under the bed and walked down the hall leading from the bedroom to the bathroom before unloading a flurry of shots through the door.

Pistorius is not claiming self-defense; he is claiming to have been mistaken about his need for self-defense. He is denying that he intentionally, unlawfully killed Steenkamp. He has never denied killing her.

The case has put the spotlight on South Africa’s rampant gun violence and high crime rates.

Roughly 45 people are murdered every day, according to police statistics, and the number of home burglaries is up 70% in the last decade.

In 2012, more than half of South Africans told the country’s police force that they were afraid of having their homes broken into. In his affidavit, Pistorius said he had been the victim of violence and burglaries before, including death threats.

CNN’s Robyn Curnow, Nick Thompson, Ashley Fantz and Susannah Cullinane contributed to this report.

™ & © 2014 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.

1 Comment

  • Eric Anderson

    Two witnesses giving the same testimony might mean they heard the same thing.

    It all hinges on when the screams were heard: Before, or after the gunshots?

    Unfortunately, that’s an extremely violent culture. Fear of home invasions is pervasive, and for good reasons.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.